You didn't post any "proof" to the contrary either, he could have been lying and just had a bad disk, which would have displayed the exact same thing. You want me to post proof, you have to first. Point void.
As for the HD impossible thing, "Surely that would be IMPOSSIBLE for a console not designed for full hd" were your exact words, so you did in fact suggest it was impossible for a console not to be designated in full HD. Point void.
Why wouldn't you ask a realtor the failure rate of a console before you purchase it.. that's basic stuff, and by your comment alone it appears you're not intelligent enough to ask around, you just purchase blindly. I know Microsoft and Sony don't tell the truth about their stats, I never said Sony didn't, I just said I wasn't stupid enough to believe a developer's word for anything to do with the problems at hand. Point void.
0 for 3 there, want to try again?